News Security news

Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook for Android accessing photo galleries without consent

On 14 November 2026 Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million. A feature in the Facebook app for Android that suggests photos and videos from the phone's gallery while you browse accessed device content without specific consent, the regulator found. Here is what the Garante decided, why it matters beyond Italy, and how to check and switch off Facebook's access to your gallery.

Kyberkit editorial team · · event date · reading time 5 minutes · For everyone

News: Meta

Key points

  • Italy's Garante fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million on 14 Nov 2026 (about 0.47% of the group's worldwide turnover) over a Facebook for Android feature that, since 2023, has suggested photos and videos from the phone's gallery while users browse.
  • According to the regulator, the app obtained gallery access through a single permission covering several features with different purposes, after a vague prompt to 'enable other features', and gallery suggestions were switched on by default.
  • The Garante relied on Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which transposes the ePrivacy Directive: merely accessing content on a phone requires free and informed consent, whether or not any data leaves the device.
  • Meta has 60 days to introduce a separate consent request and keep the feature off by default. Italian media report that Meta disagrees and plans to appeal; the Garante did not assess possible AI training or Meta's newer cloud processing of gallery content.

What happened

On Saturday 14 November 2026 Italy's data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, announced an €805 million fine against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. The regulator puts that at roughly 0.47% of the group's worldwide turnover.

The decision concerns a feature of the Facebook app for Android that the Garante refers to by its Italian name, "Ottieni suggerimenti dalla galleria quando navighi su Facebook" – in Facebook's English help pages, "Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook". Available since 2023, it surfaces photos and videos from the phone's gallery as ideas for posts while you scroll. In Italy, the regulator says, it affects about 20 million Android users.

The investigation opened in July 2025 following a complaint from the Bolzano consumer advice centre (Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti) and was backed by the authority's own technical analysis.

What the regulator objected to

According to the Garante's statement:

  • The app requested gallery access through one permission for the whole app, covering several features with different purposes.
  • The request followed a generic prompt to "enable other features" (abilitare altre funzioni), which did not make clear that gallery suggestions were part of it.
  • The feature was switched on by default.

The legal basis is Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which transposes the EU ePrivacy Directive. That provision treats a smartphone as part of the user's private sphere: access alone to content stored on the device requires free and informed consent, regardless of whether data is transmitted or any harm results.

The Garante rejected Meta's argument that the Irish regulator should handle the case, pointing out that ePrivacy, unlike the GDPR, has no one-stop-shop mechanism. In setting the amount it weighed the number of people affected, the continuing violation for users who have not updated the app, a previous 2019 decision against the company, and Meta's limited cooperation during the investigation. Changes Meta made after the complaint counted in its favour, but the regulator called them late and limited to users who update.

How Facebook for Android obtained gallery access, according to the Italian regulator1. Generic prompt to "enable other features"; 2. One photo permission for the whole app and several purposes; 3. Gallery suggestions on by default; 4. Access to device content without specific consent → breach of Art. 122 (ePrivacy)1Generic prompt to "enable otherfeatures"2One photo permission for the wholeapp and several purposes3Gallery suggestions on by default4Access to device content withoutspecific consent → breach of Art. 122(ePrivacy)
The flow the Garante found to breach consent rules (statement of 14 Nov 2026)

What Meta has to do

  • Within 60 days, ask for separate, specific consent that explains the feature, the gallery access involved and how to turn it off.
  • Keep the feature off by default, including for users who already granted the general permission.
  • If it misses the deadline, it may not enable the feature for anyone without valid consent.
  • Report its plans to the Garante within 30 days and the measures adopted within 90 days.

The regulator expressly did not examine whether Meta uses gallery content to train AI models (Meta denies it) and reserved a separate review of a newer option that processes gallery content in the cloud. Italian outlets including ANSA and Open report that Meta disagrees with the decision, considers the fine disproportionate and plans to appeal; we did not find Meta's statement in a primary source.

Who is affected

  • The fine and orders apply to Italy.
  • Meta says camera roll suggestions are available in the EU and the UK (announcement of 16 Apr 2026). Meta describes the feature as opt-in, yet its own help page says that granting camera roll access on a device turns the setting on for that device.

How to check and turn it off

In Facebook (per Facebook's help page; Android app):

  1. Tap Menu in the top-left corner.
  2. Go to Settings & privacy → Settings.
  3. Under Preferences, open Camera roll sharing suggestions.
  4. Turn off Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook. Also check that camera roll cloud processing is off.

Turning it off in Facebook applies to every device. If you grant gallery access again later, suggestions do not switch back on by themselves.

In Android (app permissions):

  1. Settings → Apps → Facebook (tap See all apps first if needed).
  2. Permissions → Photos and videos.
  3. Choose Don't allow, or on Android 14 and later allow access to selected photos only. You then pick photos manually when you post.

Exact labels vary by app version and phone manufacturer.

Timeline

Timeline of the Facebook camera roll suggestions case2019: Earlier Garante decision against Meta (aggravating factor); 2023: Gallery suggestions feature in Facebook for Android; July 2025: Garante opens investigation after Bolzano consumer centre complaint; 16 Apr 2026: Meta announces camera roll suggestions in the EU and UK; 14 Nov 2026: Garante imposes €805 million fine and 60-day deadline2019Earlier Garante decisionagainst Meta (aggravatingfactor)2023Gallery suggestions featurein Facebook for AndroidJuly 2025Garante opens investigationafter Bolzano consumer centrecomplaint16 Apr 2026Meta announces camera rollsuggestions in the EU and UK14 Nov 2026Garante imposes €805 millionfine and 60-day deadline
Based on the Garante and Meta Newsroom

Received a message "from Meta" threatening to delete your account or Page? See our guide Fake Meta message: “your Page will be deleted” scam.

Updates

  • 15 Nov 2026: first version.

FAQ

Does this affect users outside Italy?

The fine and the orders apply only in Italy. But Meta says camera roll suggestions are rolling out across the EU and the UK, so the feature may be on for you too. The Garante notes that the ePrivacy Directive has no one-stop-shop mechanism, so each national regulator can act on its own.

Did Facebook upload my photos to its servers?

The Garante's statement does not say so. In its view, simply accessing gallery content without specific consent is the violation. A separate 'camera roll cloud processing' option exists (off by default, according to Facebook's help pages), and the Garante will look at it in separate proceedings.

Does Meta use camera roll photos to train AI?

Meta says camera roll photos and videos are not used for ad targeting or to improve AI at Meta unless you publish them or share them through an AI feature. The Garante did not examine this question.

Is turning off the Facebook toggle enough?

The toggle turns suggestions off on all your devices, but the app may still hold the Android photo permission. For a firmer limit, restrict access to selected photos (Android 14 and later) or deny it in your phone's settings, then pick photos manually when you post.

Sources

  1. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali – Facebook: Italian DPA fines Meta €805 million (14 Nov 2026, Italian and English)
  2. Facebook Help Center – Enable or disable camera roll suggestions when browsing Facebook
  3. Meta Newsroom – Now Rolling Out: Facebook’s Opt‑In Camera Roll Suggestions in the EU and UK (16 Apr 2026, updated 31 Aug 2026)
  4. Android Help – Change app permissions on your Android phone

Spotted a mistake? Let us know and we will correct it openly.